On Second Thought
Scripture Reading: Colossians 2:16–23
Key Verse: Galatians 3:3
There is something unsettling about realizing you have done many things right—only to discover you were headed in the wrong direction all along. The image of the young football player crossing the goal line, celebrated by the crowd yet tragically mistaken, lingers because it mirrors a deeply human spiritual pattern. Effort was present. Desire was sincere. Energy was expended. Yet the outcome revealed a fundamental misunderstanding of orientation. Paul addresses precisely this kind of spiritual disorientation when he confronts the Galatians with a piercing question: “Are you so foolish? Having begun in the Spirit, are you now being made perfect by the flesh?” Galatians 3:3. The issue is not whether they started well—they did. The issue is whether they remembered what made the beginning possible at all.
In Colossians 2:16–23, Paul exposes the subtle drift that had taken hold of the believers’ spiritual imagination. Rules had replaced relationship. External measures of holiness had begun to crowd out inward dependence on Christ. What once flowed from gratitude for grace was now being regulated by man-made standards: food laws, sacred days, ascetic practices, and spiritual elitism. Paul does not deny discipline or discernment; rather, he challenges the source of transformation. He insists that these practices, however impressive they appear, “are of no value against the indulgence of the flesh” (Colossians 2:23). The Greek phrase ouk en timē tini underscores their inability to restrain the deeper problem of the heart. They look effective but lack power.
This is where legalism becomes especially dangerous. It disguises itself as maturity. It appeals to our desire for control, clarity, and comparison. The Colossians were not abandoning God; they were trying to secure spiritual growth apart from daily reliance on Him. Paul calls this bondage, not freedom. John Stott once noted, “The essence of legalism is the confidence that law-keeping will secure acceptance with God.” That confidence is misplaced, not because obedience is wrong, but because obedience severed from grace becomes self-justifying. The moment I believe my spiritual disciplines make me superior, I have already loosened the ball and turned toward the wrong end zone.
Judgment naturally follows legalism. When standards become externalized, others become measurable. Paul warns that once we assume the role of evaluator, we have quietly shifted from grace to flesh. This is not merely a theological error; it is a relational fracture. Spiritual pride corrodes community because it replaces humility with hierarchy. Paul’s reminder in Galatians 5:1 stands as both warning and invitation: “Stand fast therefore in the liberty by which Christ has made us free.” Freedom here is not the absence of direction but the presence of Christ. Liberty is not autonomy; it is life lived under the active guidance of the Spirit.
What makes this passage especially relevant is how easily legalism thrives in sincere environments. Churches that value holiness, discipline, and truth are often most vulnerable to confusing the fruit of the Spirit with substitutes for the Spirit Himself. The world’s influence dulls spiritual sensitivity, but religion without dependence dulls it just as effectively. Paul’s insistence is clear: growth that begins in the Spirit must continue in the Spirit. The Greek en pneumati signals both origin and ongoing means. Sanctification is not a human project with divine assistance; it is divine life expressed through surrendered obedience.
The prayer embedded in the study captures the heart of this struggle: “Father, I have begun with You. Now keep me headed the right direction.” That is not the prayer of passivity, but of alignment. It recognizes that effort without orientation leads to exhaustion, not maturity. The Christian life is not a sprint toward visible markers of success but a sustained walk shaped by trust. When Christ is central, obedience flows naturally. When rules become central, Christ recedes into the background—even while His name is spoken frequently.
On Second Thought
Here is the paradox that deserves careful reflection: the more seriously we take holiness, the more tempted we are to rely on ourselves rather than the Spirit. What begins as devotion can quietly become self-management. On second thought, many of our spiritual frustrations may not stem from a lack of discipline, but from misplaced confidence. We assume that growth requires tighter control, sharper judgment, or stricter systems, when Paul insists that true transformation comes from staying connected to Christ. The danger is not that we aim for the wrong goal, but that we pursue the right goal with the wrong power.
On second thought, legalism does not always look harsh—it often looks responsible. It promises predictability in a life of faith that requires trust. Yet faith, by nature, resists reduction to formulas. The Spirit leads, convicts, corrects, and empowers in ways that cannot be standardized. When we exchange dependence for regulation, we may still run hard, but we risk running away from the very freedom Christ secured. The wrong end zone is rarely marked by rebellion; it is more often marked by control disguised as maturity.
On second thought, the invitation of this passage is not to abandon discipline, but to re-anchor it. Spiritual practices are meant to keep us attentive to Christ, not independent of Him. The question Paul leaves us with is not whether we are running, but whether we are still being led. To continue in the Spirit is to live each day aware that the same grace that saved us is the grace that sustains us. Anything less, no matter how impressive, eventually leads us across a line we never intended to cross.
FEEL FREE TO COMMENT, SUBSCRIBE, AND REPOST, SO OTHERS MAY KNOW