On Second Thought
In John 15, Jesus offers one of His most tender and searching images: “I am the true vine, and My Father is the vinedresser” (John 15:1). Then He speaks words that are both comforting and unsettling: “You did not choose Me, but I chose you and appointed you that you should go and bear fruit, and that your fruit should remain” (John 15:16). If we are honest, most of us long for a Christian life marked by stability, comfort, and visible blessing. Francis Schaeffer once observed that many believers seem to aim primarily at personal peace and affluence. Whether we openly admit it or not, we prefer the pleasant over the painful.
Yet Jesus points us in another direction. His purpose is not merely that we be comfortable branches, but fruitful ones. The Greek word for “prunes” in John 15:2 is kathairei, which literally means “to cleanse” or “to purify.” Pruning is not punishment; it is purification. It is the careful removal of what hinders growth so that life may flow more freely. The Father is not an impatient foreman; He is a skilled Husbandman. He examines each branch with intent to increase its yield.
This reshapes how I interpret the harder seasons of life. When something is trimmed away—a habit, a relationship, a cherished ambition—I instinctively recoil. But Jesus says fruitfulness, not ease, is the goal. “Every branch that bears fruit He prunes, that it may bear more fruit” (John 15:2). Notice that pruning is not reserved for barren branches alone. Even fruitful branches are cut back. Growth in Christ often requires subtraction before multiplication.
In the rhythm of the Church calendar, particularly as we move toward seasons like Lent, we are reminded that the Christian path runs through surrender. Lent calls us to examine attachments, to lay aside distractions, and to return to the cross. That is not accidental. The vine itself bore the scars of nails. Our fruitfulness flows from a crucified Savior. The path of pruning mirrors the pattern of Christ’s own self-giving.
Jesus also clarifies something essential: “You did not choose Me, but I chose you.” The initiative belongs to Him. Before I ever considered abiding, He had already set His love upon me. The word “appointed” in John 15:16 carries the sense of being set in place for a purpose. We are not randomly attached to the vine; we are intentionally positioned. Our lives are meant to produce fruit that remains—character, obedience, love, witness.
That fruit is not self-generated. Earlier in the passage, Jesus declares, “Apart from Me you can do nothing” (John 15:5). The Christian life is not self-improvement but abiding dependence. The Greek word menō, “abide,” means to remain, to dwell, to stay connected. Pruning makes abiding more effective. When lesser attachments are severed, our communion with Christ deepens.
Still, pruning hurts. When the Lord exposes pride, strips away self-reliance, or closes doors we hoped would open, the experience can feel severe. But the tools of Providence, however sharp, are held by loving hands. Hebrews 12:11 acknowledges that discipline seems painful rather than pleasant, yet it yields the peaceful fruit of righteousness. The pain is purposeful. The cut is careful. The outcome is maturity.
Perhaps even now the Spirit has surfaced something in your life that is deleterious to your spiritual health. An attitude that sours joy. A habit that dulls sensitivity. A pursuit that crowds out devotion. The instinct is to cling, to protect what feels familiar. But the invitation of Christ is to cooperate with the Husbandman. To surrender willingly. To trust that what He removes, He replaces with greater vitality.
God’s aim is not to diminish you but to conform you to the image of His Son. The pruning knife is an instrument of transformation. In this kind of pain, there is godly gain. When the Father trims, He is not rejecting; He is refining. The branch remains in the vine, sustained by the same life-giving sap.
On Second Thought
Here is the paradox we rarely consider: the very areas we beg God to preserve may be the ones that most hinder our fruitfulness. We pray for comfort, yet Christ prays for our sanctification. We ask for relief, yet He aims for resemblance—resemblance to Himself. On second thought, perhaps the greater danger is not that God will prune too much, but that we will resist His pruning altogether.
What if the discomfort you are experiencing is not evidence of divine distance but of divine attention? A gardener does not waste time cutting lifeless wood. He prunes what has potential. The cut is proof of expectation. The Father sees in you the capacity for lasting fruit, and He refuses to let temporary attachments limit eternal impact. On second thought, the pain you resent may be the mercy you most need. The branch that endures the knife becomes the branch that carries the harvest. And when fruit appears—love steadier, faith stronger, obedience deeper—you will discover that what was removed was far less valuable than what has grown in its place.
FEEL FREE TO COMMENT, SUBSCRIBE, AND REPOST, SO OTHERS MAY KNOW