I know far too much about estrangement for one person. My mentally ill and physically abusive mother was suicidal for most of my life. Finally, when I was 25 years old, I told her we needed to go our separate ways until she could get the help she needed and just started treating people better. This wasn’t a knee-jerk reaction to one problem or disagreement. This was after years of trying to establish solid boundaries to live my life in peace, which she refused to understand or respect. Just being around her caused me so much stress that I could no longer be her caretaker and the peacekeeper of the family.
Am I Doing the Right Thing?
This made things worse by disrespecting boundaries, ignoring my need for normalcy for my children, and only proved my point that there was a need for this estrangement. After my pastor spoke to her, seeing her toxic behaviors for himself, he told me I was doing the right thing. That reassurance was so helpful, because it’s hard to know if you’re doing the right thing when you want to honor your parents as the Bible says, but you’ve always been the family peacekeeper. I was so used to taking the blame for my mother’s behavior, I had a hard time seeing this as her problem to fix and not mine.
A few years after my mother’s mental illness took her life, I was faced with an unwanted divorce. My divorce allowed me to spend years, which I’m still doing, working on my emotional health so I could clear my life of toxicity. I was done being used and abused by everyone. I had to take care of myself for once. This meant I had to narrow my inner circle and separate from a lot of people.
As I had experienced before, when toxic people are faced with boundaries and consequences for their unhealthy behaviors, they tend to lash out and pull everyone onto their side of the fence. This usually involves lies and a manipulation tactic called triangulation (telling lies to two different people to stop them from speaking to each other; gaslighting them both). They tell people that the healthier person is crazy or controlling for not allowing themselves to be walked on or treated poorly anymore.
I hear from hundreds of people every year who share that this is how they too became estranged from their children after a divorce. Because of the lies and triangulation told by ex-spouses and other family members, they were essentially erased from their children’s lives. To me, this is a different type of estrangement than what I experienced with my mother. Yet, here I am, estranged from two of my adult children too. And being blamed for it.
I’ve also talked to married couples who are estranged from their children for similar reasons. They’ve shared that other family members or friends have done the work that an ex-spouse had done in cases of divorce. As parents they had established rules that the teen or young adult didn’t like, and instead of trying to talk it out, they decided to cut the parents out of their lives because someone convinced the child that rules, boundaries, and parenting are bad things.
The reasons for estrangement do not matter, what we do about it does.
I know what it feels like to be a forgotten family member as well as an adult who’s made a life for themselves that they just want other family members to respect. These things have shaped what I believe about how to handle estrangement.
How I Handle Estrangement with My Adult Children
1. Establish Boundaries
No matter what side of the story you are on, boundaries need to be established before actions are taken. Boundaries are always words first, with an expectation that the other person will respect them, and then follow-through second if they don’t.
First, let’s look at what unhealthy boundaries look like:
1. When you expect another person to know how to treat you.
2. When you expect them to know exactly what they did wrong or guess through passive-aggressive comments.
3. When you harbor resentment towards another person but you hide it.
4. Telling someone else you’re upset with someone instead of telling the person you’re upset with.
5. Yelling or scolding someone instead of trying to have a healthy conflict-resolving and listening conversation; just showing up to argue with them.
6. Deciding to stop speaking altogether without warning or trying to resolve the issue first.
Matthew 18 tells us that we should try to talk things out first with those we have an issue with or who have sinned against us. You should tell the other person, calmly, what they did wrong and how they hurt you to seek a resolution and their repentance. You should do what you can to live in peace with everyone (Romans 12:18). But if they refuse to listen, and still want to continue the quarrel or discord, not respecting your feelings or your boundaries, then you can take one or two others with you or ask for your church’s help to try to work things out. After that, there is not much else to do but separate.
Both parents and children have the right to have boundaries for their lives. Parents can have a boundary that they won’t give out money without a relationship, or not at all if they wish. Adult children can say they don’t want their parent’s interference in their lives. And then both sides need to respect the others’ boundaries, even when it’s hard.
2. Respect Boundaries
When I told my mother that we could no longer go out to dinner with each other because I didn’t like how she spoke to the waitstaff, she didn’t feel I had a right to make that decision or even tell her how to live her life. When I told her she couldn’t take my daughter to her house anymore because she had left a bruise on her leg from the hairbrush, she called me names and said I couldn’t keep my children from her. This is disrespectfully saying to another adult, “you do not get to make your own decisions for your own life and family, even though you’re an adult.” This was her saying only she had rights and we had none.
That is why when my children decide to stop speaking to me or when they try to set a boundary, even if it’s not in the healthiest way, or cut me out of their life, I respect their choice. They are now adults (the last one is almost an adult) and I’m proud of them for making assertive decisions about their lives; I don’t want them to be me! I don’t want them to be treated how I was.
I still believe toxic people are influencing their decisions, but I don’t try to control the narrative by pushing my way past their boundaries. I want to be a healthy example, even from afar. I refuse to be disrespected but I also give that same amount of respect that I expect from others. I also trust God that the truth will eventually come out. There is nothing hidden that He won’t bring out into the light to be known by all (Luke 8:17).