When Advice Tells Us What We Want to Hear

On Second Thought

“Listen to advice and accept discipline, and at the end you will be counted among the wise.” —Proverbs 19:20

Most of us say that we want wise counsel, but what we sometimes want is confirmation. We have already decided what we prefer, and we look for someone who will tell us that our choice is reasonable, courageous, or even spiritual. Advice then becomes less like a compass showing us the right direction and more like a mirror reflecting our desires back to us.

King Rehoboam entered such a moment in 1 Kings 12:1–19. Solomon had died, and Rehoboam traveled to Shechem to be confirmed as king. The people, led by Jeroboam, approached him with a reasonable request: “Your father put a heavy yoke on us, but now lighten the harsh labor and the heavy yoke he put on us, and we will serve you.” They were not initially demanding the destruction of David’s dynasty. They were offering loyalty in exchange for relief.

Rehoboam wisely asked for three days to consider their request. He then consulted the elders who had served his father. Their advice was clear: “If today you will be a servant to these people and serve them and give them a favorable answer, they will always be your servants” (1 Kings 12:7). They understood a truth that insecure leaders often miss: authority is strengthened through service, not intimidation.

Their counsel anticipated what Jesus would later teach His disciples. When they argued about greatness, He told them, “Whoever wants to become great among you must be your servant” (Mark 10:43). Godly leadership does not ask, “How can I make people feel my power?” It asks, “How can I use the authority entrusted to me for their good?”

Rehoboam rejected the elders’ advice and turned to the young men who had grown up with him. They recommended a display of greater severity. He should tell the people that his smallest finger was thicker than his father’s waist. Where Solomon had placed a heavy yoke upon them, Rehoboam would make it heavier. Where Solomon had disciplined them with whips, he would use scorpions.

The contrast was not simply between older advisers and younger advisers. Scripture does not teach that age automatically produces wisdom or that youth has nothing valuable to contribute. The deeper distinction was between counsel that required humility and counsel that appealed to pride. The elders told Rehoboam to become a servant. His companions told him to prove that he was powerful. He chose the advice that flattered his ego.

Ungodly counsel often attracts us because it gives spiritual or practical permission to do what selfish ambition already desires.

Rehoboam’s response transformed a difficult conversation into a national rupture. Ten tribes rejected the house of David, and the united kingdom divided. His harsh answer did not demonstrate strength; it exposed insecurity. He attempted to secure control through fear and lost most of what he was trying to control.

First Kings also tells us that this turn of events fulfilled the word God had spoken through the prophet Ahijah concerning Solomon’s unfaithfulness. God’s sovereignty does not excuse Rehoboam’s foolishness. The king freely chose the counsel that suited his pride, and God incorporated that decision into His righteous judgment. Scripture can hold both truths together: God remains sovereign, and human beings remain responsible for the counsel they accept and the decisions they make.

Proverbs tells us, “Listen to advice and accept discipline, and at the end you will be counted among the wise.” The Hebrew verb shama, translated “listen,” means more than allowing words to reach our ears. It carries the idea of hearing with readiness to respond. Rehoboam heard the elders, but he did not truly listen because he was unwilling to let their wisdom redirect him.

Listening becomes especially difficult when counsel challenges our preferred course. We may dismiss the adviser as negative, old-fashioned, unsupportive, or unable to understand our circumstances. Sometimes those criticisms are justified. No human adviser is infallible. Yet our irritation may also reveal that the counsel has touched the very place where pride has been hiding.

Wise discernment begins by asking what a counselor’s advice produces. Does it lead toward the character of Christ? Does it agree with the teaching of Scripture? Does it encourage truthfulness, humility, patience, justice, mercy, and self-control? Or does it feed resentment, vanity, fear, greed, or the desire to dominate? Advice should not be judged merely by how confident the adviser sounds or how closely that person resembles us.

We should also examine whether our circle is broad enough to correct us. A leader who surrounds himself only with agreeable voices eventually loses the ability to distinguish loyalty from flattery. A friend who never challenges us may preserve our comfort while allowing us to continue toward harm. Godly counselors care enough to risk disappointing us.

Before making an important decision, we can ask the Lord to reveal our hidden motives. Am I seeking wisdom or gathering support? Have I ignored trustworthy people because their advice requires sacrifice? Have I given myself enough time to pray, listen, and test what I am hearing against Scripture? What consequences might this decision create for people who possess less power than I do?

Prayer does not replace counsel, and counsel does not replace prayer. We need both. We bring advice before God, asking Him to expose what is selfish, confirm what is faithful, and give us courage to obey. When several trustworthy believers independently warn us about the same danger, humility requires that we pause before pressing forward.

Wisdom is not demonstrated by never needing correction. Wisdom is shown by receiving correction before our pride turns a preventable mistake into lasting damage.

On Second Thought

We commonly think that strong leaders are the people who always know what to do and quickly make their decisions. Yet Rehoboam’s story suggests the opposite: the leader who cannot be redirected may be the weakest person in the room. The unexpected path to strength is teachability. Admitting, “I may be wrong,” does not diminish faithful authority; it protects authority from becoming destructive.

We may also assume that godly counsel will feel reassuring. Sometimes it does, but the counsel we most need may initially disturb us because it challenges the ambition, resentment, or fear we have mistaken for conviction. The advice that draws us nearer to God may be the advice we least want to hear. Before rejecting an uncomfortable word, we should give it time, test it by Scripture, and ask whether God is using it to rescue us from becoming another Rehoboam.

Continue receiving similar Scripture-centered reflections through Pastor Hogg’s Substack: https://substack.com/@pastorhogg.

FEEL FREE TO COMMENT, SUBSCRIBE OR POST SO OTHERS MAY KNOW