Understanding Free Will and Sin
Have you ever wondered how something as terrible as sin could arise in a place as perfect as heaven? I mean, it’s a question that’s puzzled believers for centuries: How could sinless angels, living in God’s perfect presence, choose to rebel against Him? And while the Bible doesn’t give us a detailed explanation of how or why this happened, it does provide us with some clues that can help us understand this mystery a bit better.
First, let’s talk about the idea of “givens” in Scripture. These are facts or events that the Bible states without offering an explanation. For example, the very first verse of the Bible says, “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth” (Genesis 1:1). There’s no explanation how He created everything; it’s just a given that He exists and that He is the Creator. Similarly, when we read about the earth being formless and void, or the fall of humanity, these are also presented as givens—facts that the Bible simply declares without a detailed backstory.
The same goes for the existence of sin in both angels and humans. It’s a fact that sin entered the world through the disobedience of Satan and later through Adam and Eve, but the Bible doesn’t dive into the specifics of how or why these beings, created in sinlessness, chose to rebel. This lack of explanation can be frustrating, but it’s also a reminder that some aspects of God’s creation are beyond our full comprehension. What we do know is that God, as the only perfect being in the universe, cannot create other perfect beings like Himself.
The moment He creates anything, it’s automatically less than Him and therefore imperfect, which includes the potential to choose wrongly.
The Gift of Free Will: Why Angels and Humans Had to Choose
One of the most crucial aspects of being made in God’s image is that we, like the angels, were given free will—the ability to make our own choices. Now, you might ask, “Why didn’t God just create us to always choose good?” The answer lies in the nature of true freedom. If God had preprogrammed us to only do what’s right, we wouldn’t really be free. We’d be like robots, going through the motions without any real capacity to love, obey, or even relate to God authentically.
Paul Schilling, in his book God and Human Anguish, puts it this way: If we were created without the freedom to choose, we might think we were free, but we wouldn’t be. We’d be like actors in a play, following a script without ever having a say in the story. That’s not the kind of relationship God wants with us. He desires a genuine connection, and for that to happen, we need to have the freedom to choose Him—or to choose otherwise. This freedom is what makes our love for God meaningful, but it’s also what opened the door to rebellion, both in heaven and on earth.
The freedom given to the angels, including Lucifer (who later became Satan), was real and significant. Just like humans, the angels were given the ability to choose obedience to God or to rebel. And just like humans, some chose rebellion. The Bible suggests that a third of the angels followed Lucifer in his rebellion (Revelation 12:4), and these fallen angels, or demons, are now permanently separated from God, confirmed in their evil state.
It’s a sobering thought, but it also underscores the seriousness of the choices we make.
Free will isn’t just a theoretical concept; it’s the very foundation of our relationship with God.
The Reality of Rebellion: What It Means for Us Today
So, what does all of this mean for us today? Well, it serves as a reminder that the battle between good and evil isn’t just something we read about in the Bible; it’s a reality we face every day. Satan, the originator of rebellion, is still active in the world, leading his army of fallen angels in their ongoing fight against God’s purposes (Ephesians 6:12). But here’s the good news: while Satan may have power, he doesn’t have the final say. Jesus Christ has already won the ultimate victory through His death and resurrection, and through Him, we have the power to resist the enemy and stand firm in our faith.
This also challenges us to take our own choices seriously. Just as the angels had to choose between obedience and rebellion, we too face daily decisions that either draw us closer to God or pull us away from Him. Are we choosing to follow God’s will, even when it’s difficult, or are we allowing ourselves to be swayed by the temptations of the world? The reality of free will means that our choices matter, not just in the big moments, but in the small, everyday decisions that shape our lives and our relationship with God.
In summary, the rebellion in heaven and on earth is a stark reminder of the power of free will and the consequences of our choices. But it’s also a call to action. We’re not helpless in the face of temptation; through the Holy Spirit, we have the strength to choose obedience and to live in a way that honors God. Let’s make the most of the freedom we’ve been given by choosing to live for Christ every day.
PLEASE COMMENT, SHARE, SUBSCRIBE